Synopsis
A NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER
From bestselling author Stephen Graham Jones comes a “masterpiece” (Locus Magazine) of a novel about revenge, cultural identity, and the cost of breaking from tradition. This is a remarkable horror story that “will give you nightmares—the good kind of course” (BuzzFeed).
From New York Times bestselling author Stephen Graham Jones comes a novel that is equal parts psychological horror and cutting social commentary on identity politics and the American Indian experience. Fans of Sylvia Moreno Garcia and Tommy Orange will love this story as it follows the lives of four American Indian men and their families, all haunted by a disturbing, deadly event that took place in their youth. Years later, they find themselves tracked by an entity bent on revenge, totally helpless as the culture and traditions they left behind catch up to them in a violent, vengeful way.
In this “thrilling, literate, scary, [and] immersive” (Stephen King) tale, Jones blends his signature storytelling style with a haunting narrative that masterfully intertwines revenge, cultural identity, and tradition.
Review
I own the audiobook (and the paperback), so I was able to give it a quick re-listen in preparation for the sequel, Off the Reservation, which releases today, 10/13/26!
Four friends sneak onto the hunting ground reserved for their Indian elders. As young men, they think the reward is worth the risk. A final elk or two for their freezers this winter and none the wiser, right? What they find instead not only gets them in trouble with the reservation, but will leave lasting trauma and repercussions as revenge bubbles just beneath the snowy ground. This is an incredibly cultural, personal narrative that feels like horror smashed with the author’s real world.
I first read this story in 2020, which was probably going on right around the time of opening up to more horror. And while much of that widening of my horizon involved watching rather than reading, this was one of the first, newer attempts at the genre. And I remember it really not working for me. And that makes this the perfect example of how my tastes have changed and evolved over time. I distinctly remember the scene with the ladder and teeth turning my stomach. Not only was it going too far, but it wasn’t really something I would ever read continuously. I wasn’t ready to associate any kind of blood and gore with horrors that remarked upon things far beyond just what was being shown. I missed the author’s hints connecting everything back to the past, to the event that spawned all of this. And on a reread, not only was it a pretty “normal” incident by now (no less brutal or hard-hitting, though), but I did catch all of the nuance, and I really enjoyed the story. I completely flip-flopped from around a 2* to a 5*. And I’m sure people are tired of hearing about it at this point, but I mean it when I say I really did not do horror back in the day. Of any kind. I think this serves as a great example of that. And why bother reading the sequel if I didn’t like this, you may ask? Well, since then, I’ve read The Night Cyclist, Parthenogenesis, I Was a Teenage Slasher, and Mapping the Interior, all of which I thoroughly enjoyed. This novel deserved a second try in my eyes, and I was right.
The cultural commentary is a heavy one. SGJ fears nothing and shows the reader just how the world has shaped their perception of Indians in America. Prejudices to outright racism. And not only that, but the author digs in his heels to give us a point-blank examination of how, in ways, they’ve grown to view themselves. This almost-generational pride that often looks more like guilt, reluctant communal strength. As someone who’s 34 and a lifelong New Yorker, I cannot actually recall if I’ve ever interacted with anyone from a tribe, and although I have been on a reservation in the past, it was not a long visit nor educational. Sometimes getting the firsthand, unfiltered perspective is more educational than someone teaching anyway. Even if you’re not into horror, that’s a reason to check out the author’s writing anyway.
There is a cross-examination on display here between the pride, guilt, and identity of being Indian that feeds seamlessly into this novel’s revenge story. Yes, the spirit of an elk is a direct line, but it’s in the delivery and what isn’t on the page that mirrors between them so well. They were only hunting as any Good Indian should. Yes, they shouldn’t have been there, but they were partaking in a reservation staple. Once caught, the meat was given back to the elders as any Good Indian should do. I find a lot of this novel to be about trying to answer how you can feel both righteous and guilt-ridden at the same time, about even the same things.
The author filters a love of basketball right onto the page. The descriptions of dribbling, shooting, and even their stances all felt like genuine knowledge. It also reminded me of Malerman’s Daphne in the way it captured the desire and drive to succeed. It also includes a climactic 1 v 1 game as well, of course, and there’s just something about how the author threaded the sport through the novel that makes the final delivery really soar.
I will say, between the first listen and the second, I believe I went from listening to audiobooks at normal speed to about x1.5-1.75. As this is most definitely a real slow burn, I think that might actually have helped my enjoyment compared to the first go-around. But for those reading the book physically or on an e-reader (or even at normal speed!), it is 100% a book that you should stick with, and let me tell you, once it takes off, it most certainly goes explosive. The climax is atmospheric, dangerous, poetic, and gut-wrenching. It gives the reader everything they were waiting—hoping—for! This book is creeping, eerie madness. It will sneak up on you too.
Leave a Reply